Wimpys Burger Basket

Reviews

• Nicole D.

  star star star star star 31 May 2026

  WE LOVE WIMPY'S!! Hands down best garbage plate in the area - the whole plate is so large that we usually split it and leave extra full (though, it would be OK to go for a whole one and not split because who doesn't love a garbage plate?!).
  
  The place is clean and they have all these dollar bills on the wall that we love to look at when we come in. The service has always been quick and friendly.
  
  For our plate, we always go with our go-to: two cheeseburgers, home fries, extra chili sauce, mac salad with all the condiments loaded on top. They do give you a roll on the side, with butter and extra condiments on the counter. YUM!
  
  They have super late hours which is nice if craving a late night snack, and they also have a pretty large menu with burgers, fries, chicken sandwiches, etc., so you don't have to go for the garbage plate if you don't want to, though I'd suggest it.

• Tom M.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 29 May 2026

  We came as a group before End Game.
  It took a fair amount of time for our orders to be filled.
  
  One would have thought everything would have been fresh cooked and hot given the amount of time. Sadly that was NOT the case.
  
  The friend who headed up the night wanted to chime here because they had the"best" burgers.
  
  Or local standards of Bill Gray's and Tom Wahl's beat them hands down. Wendy's and Burger King do, too. This night even McD's Big Mac bests them Jlhand's down and their fries would have been crisp and h, not cold and limp.

• Jeffery M.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 20 May 2026

  Food quality is horrible, ordered 4 cheeseburger plates and side order of fries. On each order placed I asked for well done deep fried home fries and French fries, cashier said sir they are all deep fried and well done! Got my order and the home fries were soggy, so undercooked/raw. Asked for everything on my plate, had a huge pile of onions, no ketchup and hardly nothing else. Meat sauce and burgers had no taste, mac salad was watery. Highly don't recommend, many other choices for good quality food/plates near by..

• Joe S.

  star star star star star 20 May 2026

  Most underrated garbage plate in Rochester. I love the recipe for Mac salad and it always goes well with fries! In my attached photo I had a chicken finger plate w/ max salad, fries, and meat sauce/mustard/no onions. The total cost came out to be around 8 dollars. Overall very pleased with Wimpys food!

• Dominique V.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 7 May 2026

  Ordered from uber eats, some wings (well done) and some pizza logs. The time kept getting pushed back further and further so I thought they had decided to keep my wings down longer which made me happy. Finally my order comes almost at 1am when I ordered it around 11. No sauce for the pizza logs and the wings were cold and NOT EVEN CLOSE TO WELL DONE. Maybe I'll come in and give it a try that way but this was not gonna make me wanna do that sooner rather than later.